Dadi vs Legacy: Which At-home Male Fertility Kit is Right for YOU?






Our editors independently research, review, and recommend the best products. We may receive commissions on some (not all) purchases made from our chosen links. Learn more.

You want to have children someday – great. But, can you? 

This is a question that a lot of men (of all ages) aren’t asking themselves, but they should be. Considering the fact that about 15% of couples will experience infertility issues, it’s incredibly important to understand if you and your partner are healthy enough to conceive. 

Another issue is that traditional fertility clinics can reach over $1,000, and just the process, alone, is a turn-off for some. Driving to a lab, masturbating in a bathroom, and then waiting for your results is not the ideal way to test your fertility as a guy (or spend a Saturday afternoon, for that matter). Luckily, companies like Dadi and Legacy are aiming to change that. With simple, at-home male fertility kits, Dadi and Legacy are making it easier than ever to test if your semen is healthy enough to start the family you’ve always dreamed of. On top of that, they’re more affordable than traditional, in-person clinics. This means that you and your partner can save up for all the other expenses that come with being a parent. 

Fortunately for consumers, new DTC (direct to consumer) male fertility kits have started coming to market over the past few years. Today, we’ll be taking a closer look at two of the industry leaders: Dadi vs Legacy. We’ll break down their price points, examine the pros and cons of both, and help you understand which male fertility kit might be best for you and your partner. Because while they’re both very much in the same space, Dadi and Legacy do have some key differences.

south park fertility clinic gif

What is a male fertility kit and how do I use it?

Simply put, male fertility kits offered by Dadi and Legacy are at-home methods of testing your semen. Both offer a very simple, 5-step process, and even offer long-term cryopreservation for your semen. By offering men an extremely rigorous and analytical look into the health of their sperm, as well as ongoing support and coaching, Dadi and Legacy are maximizing the chances that you’ll be able to have a child some day. 

STEP 1: Order your kit

Once you’ve completed a quick registration process online, Dadi and Legacy will discreetly ship a fertility kit to your doorstep. 

STEP 2: Deposit your semen sample

AKA, the best part. 😉 While this step may seem simple, there are some instructions involved as there are a variety of ways that a sperm sample can be contaminated. Along with that, sending your sample back as quickly as possible is imperative for accurate results. Sperm doesn’t have a long life span, and as soon as it is outside of your body it begins to die. 

Once you’ve carefully read through the instructions and mapped out your sperm’s voyage back to the labs of Dadi or Legacy, you can begin the process of depositing your little swimmers into the kit. You may feel like you’ve finished, but now it’s time to actually finish shipping your sample so it can be tested and/or cryopreserved. 

STEP 3: Test your sample

Get ready for the most interesting trip to the Post Office you’ve ever had. Dadi and Legacy allow you to securely ship your sample back to their CLIA-certified labs for analysis. Dadi operates out of the New England Cryogenic Center, while Legacy runs their own CLIA-certified lab.

Dadi has a turnaround time of just 24 hours for getting your results, from the time you ship your kit. 

Legacy’s turnaround time is around 24-48 hours and you can even arrange for them to pick up your sample. This ensures smooth transit back to their lab.  

STEP 4: Review your fertility report

Once your sperm has been analyzed in their labs, you’ll receive a full fertility report.

Both Dadi and Legacy’s reports provide you a deep look at the data, analysis, and recommendations. They’re both arguably as rigorous as any fertility clinic as you’ve visited, giving you insights into your sperm count, concentration volume, etc. Nonetheless, Legacy’s fertility report can’t be beat. More on that later. 

dadi fertility report
Dadi - sample fertility report
Legacy fertility report analysis
Legacy - sample fertility report

STEP 5: Store your sperm (Optional step, sperm storage is only for future use)

Dadi and Legacy both offer sperm storage options for an annual fee. Dadi even separates your sample into 3 separate vials so that you have 3 chances to fertilize an egg at a later date if you so choose. Both companies have 24/7 surveillance of their storage facilities, so you can rest easy knowing your swimmers are being protected. Depending on whether you choose Dadi or Legacy, and how long you want to freeze your sperm, this may come at an additional cost.

Who should consider using male fertility kits?

Unfortunately, infertility rates amongst men are on the rise in the United States. 1 out of 10 men are infertile, which means this is something that should be more openly discussed amongst males of all ages. And for our female readers, please consider having this talk with your man. 

I’m constantly amazed by the innovation that D2C businesses create for consumers. At-home fertility testing is no exception. Dadi and Legacy are both building upon the traditional male fertility testing experience, without sacrificing quality or expertise. They’re great for men who are:

  • Looking to start a family,
  • Wanting to ensure their ability to start a family later down the road,
  • Proactive about their health, 
  • Nervous about fertility clinics and would prefer to handle things from home,
  • Are not comfortable spending a ton, OR are comfortable with paying more for an extremely premium experience (no matter your budget, there’s something for you)
man opening dadi kit in home

There is a general assumption that conceiving a child is easy, when in reality, it is anything but. It takes planning, perseverance, and knowledge. For some it can be a challenge, and with busy schedules, taking the time to go to a fertility lab just isn’t realistic. That’s exactly the problem that Dadi and Legacy are solving. Gone are the days of stuttering through awkward conversations with a doctor or lab technician about your semen in front of your significant other. And even better, so are the days of forking out over $1000 for a fertility report. 

If you want to start a family, care about your health, and want to avoid the awkwardness of ejaculating into a cup at a fertility clinic, these at-home kits are the perfect solution. Plus, you can use your own… uh, source material… instead of the sticky magazines at the clinic. 

How much do male fertility kits cost?

One of the biggest positives of at-home fertility kits like Dadi or Legacy is just how affordable they are. Both companies offer 3 package options depending on whether or not you just want quick results or long-term storage of your sperm. 

Below we’ve broken down individual costs and features between the Dadi and Legacy kits: 

Pricing: Dadi vs Legacy

Dadi logo transparent Legacy logo transparent
FDA Approved?
Cost of At-Home Fertility Kit$199 (basic kit)
$299 (advanced kit)
$599 (add'l storage)
$195 (Year)
$995 (Five Year)
$3,995 Lifetime
Coupon codesUse code ZEN25 for $25 off
Storage Included?1 year included
Cost of Add'l Storage$99 per year$145 per year (or $99/yr for 5 years)
Cost of Morphology Analysis$99Included
Level of Analysis and RecommendationsStandard or Advanced report Top tier, more comprehensive than Dadi
Location of Semen AnalysisNew England Cryogenic Center (CLIA certified)Runs its own CLIA certified Lab
Fertility Results Turnaround Time24 hours24-48 hours
States supportedAll 50 statesAll 50 states
Video of Sperm Included in Report?
FSA / HSA Eligible
Calibre of Medical StaffRegistered Nurse (RN)RNs, Urologists, and Fertility Specialists
Multi-geographic Storage (a safety precaution)
Security2FA2FA + Persona identity verification
Able to verify a vasectomy (post-vas)?
Website

The fun doesn’t stop there, though. Dadi includes one free year of sperm storage with the purchase of every kit they offer. By default, they highlight three packages to help you get started, based on the amount of sperm you want to collect and store. But if you want a more customized package, it’s no problem at all (more on that in a sec).

dadi logo

Dadi Kit review and breakdown

I dug into Dadi’s history a bit, since they’re a pretty interesting company. When originally starting Dadi, founder Tom Smith had one main goal in mind: to make male fertility more widely talked about. After hearing about a friend’s expensive and outdated experience at a fertility clinic, he figured there must be a better way for men to access their fertility results. Since 2018, that’s exactly what Dadi has been doing. 

Dadi makes it incredibly easy for men to test their fertility at home. You simply order a kit online, deposit your sperm sample from the comfort of your home, and send it back via FedEx. Within 24 hours of receiving your sample, a lab technician will assess your sample and a full fertility report will be sent your way. This report includes the volume of your sperm, its concentration, and even a video of your little swimmers that you and your partner can geek out over.  

product shot of open dadi kit
The most fun you'll have this Christmas!

Let’s dive into Dadi’s three plans:

Dadi Kit – Tier 1

Dadi’s $199, base kit gets you their standard fertility test, and one free year of cryopreservation of three three vials of sperm.

 

Good for: Basic fertility testing.

Dadi Kit – Tier 2

For $299, you upgrade to an advanced fertility report + the ability to book consultative calls with Dadi’s Registered Nurses. If you care about the video, this is the plan you want.

 

Good for: More in-depth data and handholding. 

Dadi Kit – Tier 2

Dadi’s highest-priced plan comes in at $599. You’ll revert to their standard fertility test, but upgrade to the ability to store up to nine vials of semen.

 

Good for: People who are looking to store as much semen as possible.

Ok, now back to customized plans. Say you don’t immediately click with any of these plans – you want to order one fertility kit and start small with paying for four years of storage. Dadi makes it extremely easy to build your own a-la-carte plan at checkout. You can pre purchase additional years of storage, buy additional kits, or purchase advanced diagnostics (morphology)  and a nursing consultation. Dadi makes is super easy to customize based on your fertility and family planning needs.

Facts and figures aside, Dadi is one of the true pioneers of the at-home fertility testing space. Their website is pretty, their product offerings are clearly laid out and explained, and you can shop with the confidence knowing they’re a venture backed company. Having gained the trust of investors to the tune of $7,000,000 in funding, Dadi is here to stay. And so are your healthy, little swimmers.   

A closer look at Dadi Kit's fertility reports

Alright so generally, Dadi’s fertility report is not as exhaustive as Legacy’s. But for a lot of guy’s out there, that’s not really an issue. Every man (and couple) is at a different stage in their journey, everyone’s situation is unique, and it may not be necessary to collect every possible data point under the sun. Especially when you bring price into the equation. 

Dadi offers two different tiers of fertility reports: their standard report and the advanced one. Here’s how they’re different: 

Dadi's standard fertility report

Again, this is the report you can expect to get if you went with either Dadi’s $199 plan or their $599 plan. The standard report includes the standard stuff you’d see at a traditional fertility clinic: sperm count, concentration, volume, and motility. They’ll also benchmark your numbers against the general male population, so you can see how you stack up. 

dadi kit fertility report

Dadi's advanced fertility report

If you opt for Dadi’s middle-tier plan for $299, you’re getting two main perks:

1 – Upgrade to the advanced fertility report. 

So what, exactly, does the word “advanced” refer to? Pretty simple actually. It refers to the addition of sperm morphology. (Previously, Dadi charged $99 for this perk. So right off the bat, if this is something you would’ve considered paying more for, you should probably choose this plan over the $199 one.) 

dadi kit morphology report

2 – One-on-one consultation with Dadi’s in-house Registered Nurses. 

This is great for people who sort of understand the importance of all these fertility data points, but think that even after seeing the report and benchmark figures, would benefit from having an actual consultative call with an RN. Two quick notes on this:

  • Registered Nurses are great. But on the off-chance that your sample raises a red flag (that is to say, something is abnormally wrong), RNs just simply don’t have the same level of expertise as physicians or urologists. So if you do find yourself in this situation, you’ll likely want to open a dialogue with someone who’s truly mastered this specialization. 
  • Secondly, Legacy offers this perk for free. Unlimited, complementary calls with their team of RNs, physicians, and urologists. 

I can’t tell you whether or not the advanced fertility report is “better” or “worth it,” but as someone who would always appreciate professional guidance (especially considering how important all of this is!), I would personally shell out the extra $100 for these upgrades.

Dadi Kit promo code

🎉 Dadi has extended an exclusive promo code to our readers. If you use code ZEN25 at checkout, you’ll get $25 off any Dadi Kit.

Dadi Kit Reviews: What are others on the internet saying?

Average rating (28 reviews)
4.4/5

Legacy Kit review and breakdown

How does someone come up with the idea to start a company that tests sperm and keeps it secure for future use? For Legacy founder and CEO Khaled Kteily, it was the combination of having a friend with a cancer diagnosis who was suggested by his doctor to freeze his sperm, and a spilled Starbucks tea. Yes, a spilled tea that led to Kteily having 2nd degree burns on his legs and lap. Speaking as a man, spilling hot tea on my lap resulting in 2nd degree burns would have me desperate to know that everything down there is still functioning properly. Apparently, Kteily had the same idea and was able to turn his painful experience into a company that is backed by $15.3M of investor funding, paving the way for at-home fertility tests for men. 

Legacy is more expensive than Dadi – pretty much across the board. But in their case, you really do get what you pay for. Let’s walk through WHY Legacy charges more than Dadi, and why customers still flock to them. 

Legacy not only provides you a kit to test your sperm, but they’ll also set you up with a personal Client Service Advisor to help you throughout every step of the process. Since not everyone is an “at-home sperm test kit” professional, the extra attention to the client is a great thing to have and can help put a lot of men at ease when thinking about their fertility. You can even schedule a video call with a (complementary) fertility specialist to further explain your results. 

I mentioned earlier how Legacy’s fertility report is more vigorous and actionable than Dadi’s. Not only do they cover all the same bases as Dadi (minus the video), but they also:

  1. Test DNA fragmentation*,
  2. Include morphology in their base pricing,
  3. Include telehealth appointments with Registered Nurses, physicians, and urologists,
  4. Offer more intuitive, actionable recommendations on how you can adjust your lifestyle to improve the health of your sperm.

Generally, Legacy offers you more expertise and support in the way of (complementary) advisory telehealth calls with fertility specialists and their in-house urologist. Dadi offers calls with nurses for $99/call. The step up from that, to what Dadi offers, is definitely notable because nurses are not as qualified as doctors and urologists when dealing with severe cases. Hopefully you’re not someone who has to experience a severe case (knock on wood), but there’s a certain level of comfort in knowing that you’re in good hands, if a more difficult case does arise.

*A note on DNA fragmentation, because I went down a bit of a rabbit hole trying to understand what the heck it is:

What is DNA fragmentation?

DNA fragmentation refers to a pretty advanced analysis done on semen that determines how “damaged” the DNA is. The higher percentage of fragmentation, the higher likelihood that there will be an issue with the pregnancy. Of course we all know that correlation ≠ causation, meaning it’s not quite at the level of “x% of DNA fragmentation means you’re y% more likely to have a miscarriage”. And for that reason, DNA methodology isn’t really a “given” in the industry. 

But DNA fragmentation is still valuable because it helps couples understand the risks coming from the male partner, including time to pregnancy, risk of miscarriage, and likelihood of congenital conditions. This is particularly important for couples that have had miscarriages. High DNA fragmentation is an indicator for the couple to try IVF. 

Legacy offers DNA fragmentation (For Tomorrow and Forever plans); Dadi does not.

Moving on. For those of you that are looking to store your sperm for future use, Legacy offers cryogenic storage (AKA cryopreservation) at an additional fee of either $14.95/month (AKA $145/year for annual storage) or $495 for 5 years. Like Dadi, Legacy has 3 different “tiers” for customers to choose from: 

For Today

Legacy’s base kit, the For Today plan, is $195, is great for those that just want a quick analysis of your fertility (like 23andMe, but just for sperm). Again, this includes a free morphology analysis of your sperm, and Legacy’s fertility report is, overall, more comprehensive. Even Legacy’s default fertility report seems more detailed than Dadi’s Advanced ($299) plan. 

Keep in mind, though, that this option only includes 1 week of storage. So if you’re looking for a combination of analysis + storage, you’ll likely want to tack on a year or two of storage (at $145/year). 

This plan DOES include a complimentary telehealth call (with nurses and doctors), as well as an onboarding call and 24/7 support from their Client Experience team. 

For Tomorrow

Alright, you’re looking for a bit more than a standard fertility test. You want real results, real guidance, and most importantly: you’re planning ahead and want the peace of mind in knowing you’ve got healthy swimmers frozen away in multiple labs. 

Legacy’s second tier comes in at $995, but includes a whopping five years of sperm storage. You’ll, of course, still get direct access to a top-notch fertility specialists that can help answer any questions you may have regarding your fertility. This plan also includes DNA fragmentation in the fertility report, free of charge. 

Forever

Welcome to the big leagues. If you’re not a young, strapping lad and those two plans don’t do it for you, you can invest $3,995 for analysis and lifetime storage. This may sound expensive, but Legacy also includes a one-time transfer of your sperm to anywhere in the world at any time when you purchase this option. So if you want your sperm to see the world, this is the perfect option for you. 

Legacy is the real deal. Their board of advisors is stacked with fertility professionals from all across the world, so if you’re questioning whether or not to get tested for fertility (or where to look), Legacy would certainly be a good place to turn for answers.  

Legacy Reviews: What are others out there saying?

Legacy has some pretty killer feedback from customers across Trustpilot, Google Reviews, and their own site. They often speak highly of their customer support, ease of use, and the friendly (and confidential) nature of receiving their test results from Legacy. It’s very clear that they’re a customer-first company who’s dedicated to making people feel comfortable about the entire fertility testing experience.

Take a look at a few we’ve compiled:

Hypothetical Cost Scenarios: Dadi vs Legacy

We’re almost to the end, fellas. But bear with me for a couple more minutes because I’d like to give a couple quick hypothetical scenarios, to compare real-world, basic options between Dadi and Legacy. 

Scenario #1

You’re a 34 year old guy. Generally healthy and no problems with your sexual health (to your knowledge). Lately, your fiance has been looking into her own fertility health, so you figured you’d look into your own, too. You’re looking to fit a few different criteria:

  1. You want a fairly advanced fertility report done on your semen sample. Nothing crazy (so no DNA fragmentation, this time around), but also enough to make all of this worthwhile.
  2. You are open to sitting down and reviewing your report with someone who is (no offense) more qualified than you are, in this area. It’s not a “must-have,” but if it’s cost-effective, why not? 
  3. You don’t care about storage, at this point in time. You just want to see how healthy your swimmers are, to know if any more immediate action is required.

With Dadi Kit, this would cost: 

$299 for their Tier-2, Advanced Fertility plan. 

This plan includes morphology.

This plan includes the ability to sit down with an RN. 

With Legacy, this would cost: 

$195 for their For Today plan.

Their report is more comprehensive and actionable, but let’s call them equal.

This plan includes a telehealth appointment with a nurse or doctor (which is an upgrade from Dadi).

In this scenario, Legacy is the obvious move. 

BUT if in this scenario, you wanted to tack on a couple years of storage, the incremental cost with Legacy would outweigh things pretty quickly. You’d be looking at $398 for Dadi and $485 for Legacy. 

That was fun, right? Let’s do another one. 

Scenario #2

You’re not messing around. You recognize the fact that you’re getting older, and with all this talk about how men’s testosterone levels drop off after 40, you’re ready to do everything in your power to maximize your chances of having a mini-me someday. Especially since your 37 year old wife had a tragic miscarriage last year. Here’s what you’re thinking: 

You want an advanced fertility analysis, including morphology. Given your wife’s past miscarriage, you’d be open to getting the additional data of DNA fragmentation, but it’s not necessarily a deal-breaker.

Again, you definitely want to review the report with a fertility specialist. A Registered Nurse should do the trick, but given all the variables at play here (and the clock’s ticking), this will be an important discussion. Whoever you speak with has to have enough experience to help you navigate the course. 

You’re not rushing into IVF or anything, but you’re aiming to make moves some time in the next 4 years. So let’s get 4 years of cryopreservation. 

With Dadi Kit, this would cost $596: 

$299 for their Tier-2, Advanced Fertility plan. 

This plan includes morphology. No option to get a DNA fragmentation analysis done, but again, that’s more of a “nice-to-have” anyway.

This plan includes the ability to meet with an RN. This does give you a bit of pause, however, since they’re not quite as experienced as a physician or urologist.

+ 3 years of additional storage at $99/year.

With Legacy, this would cost $690: 

$195 for their For Today plan, + 4 years of storage @ $145/year. This is around $790. But at that point, you’d actually be better off buying 5 years of storage @ $99/year, which puts things at $690.

Their report is more comprehensive and actionable. So they get the leg up there.

This plan includes a telehealth call with a nurse/doctor.

 

Price-wise, Dadi wins this one by checking off all your boxes for around $100 less. But keep in mind that while they do cover all the bases, they’re not necessarily blowing Legacy out of the park. 

As I’ve mentioned, Legacy’s entire customer journey is built around your comfort and ease. Their fertility report is more comprehensive, their staff is more experienced, and they offer multi-geographic storage of your semen (just in case).

The Consensus: Which fertility kit is better, Dadi vs Legacy?

Cases like this sometimes make it difficult to try and compare companies like apples to apples. 

When it comes down to it, there really is no clear winner between Dadi and Legacy in terms of the efficacy of their male fertility testing. Both companies offer a kit that will deliver a detailed fertility report just as thorough as what you’d get with the in-person, traditional clinic. They also offer cryostorage at competitive prices, giving you a reliable and long-term solution. And in terms of price, both Dadi and Legacy offer their starting fertility packages at around $200. (A bit less for Dadi, if you use code ZEN25 for $25 off).

If you’re looking for a quick and detailed fertility report, Dadi could be a good option for you. Dadi’s free year of storage is a considerable factor for couples that are just dipping their toes in the water and planning for the future, and the flexibility in how you can create your own customized plan gives them a leg up on Legacy. This is a big one so I’ll repeat it: The flexible, “a-la-carte” nature of Dadi’s plans makes it extremely easy to “create” a plan that works for your needs and your budget. Legacy’s plans lack this flexibility (other than purchasing additional years of storage). 

Dadi’s $299 plan does offer a call with a nurse to walk you through your fertility report and can help advise on local fertility centers, like for IVF, but remember that they lack the expertise that Legacy’s fertility team has. So if you’re looking at Dadi’s lower price and thinking it’s a no-brainer, just keep this in mind.   

As for Legacy: this company is VERY focused on helping their customers. Their lower priced tier ($195) is comparable to Dadi’s. And while it doesn’t come with a cool video of your swimmers, their fertility report and analyses truly are unmatched. The mere fact that they offer DNA fragmentation really does show how comprehensive, thorough, and forward-thinking they are. 

You may also like to know that Legacy runs their own CLIA certified labs and offers multi-geographic storage, meaning if disaster were to strike one of their labs, you can rest assured you have other vials stored around the world. That, combined with their team of Urologists, Registered Nurses, and Fertility Specialists should help paint the picture of just how focused these guys are on male fertility. They’re bonafide fertility experts who are seeking to make your fertility journey as easy, transparent, and successful as possible.

For the couple that wants to spend a little extra premium for more 1:1 consultation throughout their fertility test journey, Legacy is the one for you. it’s clear that they are built for one thing and one thing only – to make this entire experience pleasurable for men and couples alike. Their higher priced offerings may seem like a lot to some, but when it comes to your fertility and planning a family, it may be a premium worth paying. Your kids will probably agree. 🙂

 
Andrew Clark

Andrew Clark

I studied Communications and Business at Chapman University. After my time in Orange County, I relocated back home to the Bay Area and have spent the last 6 years working in technology. My free time is usually spent on the golf course or exploring all the beautiful areas California has to offer.